Mystic Island Real Estate
Most Popular
109 E Mohawk Drive
$414,000
Most Expensive
33 W Mullica Road
$550,000
Least Expensive
964 Center Street
$260000
Mystic Island Listings Summary
Mystic Island - Town vs. County Stats
Avg Price in Mystic Island: $417,300 / County Avg $980,100
43%
Avg Taxes in Mystic Island: $5,400 / County Avg $8,900
61%
Avg Sq. Ft. in Mystic Island: 1,152 / County Avg 2,072
56%
Avg Price per/sqft in Mystic Island:$362 / County Avg $473
77%
Avg Year Built in Mystic Island: 1968 / County Avg 1982
99%
Avg Days on Website in Mystic Island: 80 / County Avg 85
94%
Mystic Island Real Estate Market Health
New Listings
Reductions
Foreclosures
Short Sales
All information is believed to be accurate but is not guaranteed. Protected by Copyright© 2026 and is owned either by the Monmouth County Association of REALTORS; or by the developers of the software, Kunversion, LLC. All rights reserved. Each office independently owned and operated.
The New Jersey Real Estate Commission requires every licensed broker or salesperson with whom you list your property to give you a copy of this notice. The purpose is to help you comply with the New Jersey Law
